Traded Away
Recent developments prove that, when the chips are down, nothing is sacred.
Last month’s NHL trade deadline brought the abrupt departure of the brightest star in the Tampa hockey universe. After 13 seasons, Martin St. Louis, the Tampa Bay Lightning’s team captain and six-time All-Star, was dealt to the New York Rangers for their captain, Ryan Callahan, and two draft picks. Asked whether the deal made the Lightning a better team, general manager and former Red Wings great Steve Yzerman replied, “I don’t know. We’re different. We’ll see.”
As a season-ticket holder, I attend almost every home game and keep my ears up for news. I knew the deadline was approaching and I knew St. Louis had asked for a trade. I guess I was kidding myself when I assumed that Yzerman would patch up his relationship with his captain, whom he had recently snubbed when building the Canadian Olympic team’s roster. (St. Louis joined the gold medal-winning squad as an injury replacement.) These are grown men, after all, and the desires of the fans should come first. Unfortunately, their inability to work out their differences has left the rest of us out in the cold.
Unlike Lightning fans, it seems that car buyers are getting exactly what they want on a regular basis. This issue includes two articles that prove it. Our cover story profiles a Southern California dealership that adopted a no-haggle pricing model after partnering with TrueCar. Both companies have joined the growing list of retailers, including America’s largest, AutoNation, that have decided that fixed prices are the way of the future. Studies quoted in the article and elsewhere seem to demonstrate that customers prefer no-haggle pricing. From its inception, CarMax has proven that used-car buyers are willing to pay a premium to get it.
CarMax’s sales process also plays into the next story, the second in a series about dealer management systems by Brian Reed of F&I Express. A tireless proponent of the paperless dealership, the author challenges us to picture a future in which the entire car-buying transaction is executed online. He acknowledges that premise could threaten the revenue stream generated by the finance office. But, as he points out, CarMax has prospered under an F&I process that generally relies on self-selection.
I am not suggesting you should model your operation after CarMax, and I don’t guess that Brian would either. The takeaway here is that customers are forcing dealers to rethink and, in some cases, abandon outdated or otherwise irrelevant processes. You have done it before. Consider, for example, the difference between the F&I office of today and that of 20 years ago. The old tips and tricks have given way to a fully transparent process designed to please educated customers.
Progress comes in many forms. Sometimes we seek it; other times it is thrust upon us. Will fixed prices and fully online sales transactions gain traction? Will widespread adoption improve our industry? I don’t know. We’re different. We’ll see.
More Dealer Ops

Dealership Profits Decline
While new and used retail sales stagnated, dealerships have been particularly supported by fixed operations and finance-and-insurance profits, according to a new report.
Read More →
Dealer Debrief: Defection Data & EV Updates
In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses how to use defection data to your advantage and the latest on EV sales and charging infrastructure.
Read More →
How Defection Data is Bridging the Dealership Conversion Gap
Lead volume is flat, cross-shopping is up and brand loyalty is in retreat. As confident sales teams keep losing buyers they thought they had, daily industry sales data is showing dealers exactly where their funnel is breaking and how to fix it without buying a single new lead.
Read More →
Dealer Debrief: Where are you losing customers?
In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses the hidden leaks in dealerships where you might be losing customers without even realizing it.
Read More →
Dealer Debrief: Improving Your Inventory Management
In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers a new survey that shows what service technicians really want and two launches that could help improve your inventory and vehicle life cycle management.
Read More →
Ladies and Gentlemen, This Is a Dealership: Why the Fundamentals Still Decide Who Wins
A teaching moment by a legendary football coach happens to apply perfectly in the auto retail space. Learn what it is and how to use it to your store’s advantage.
Read More →
Dealer Ads and the FTC
The agency has made it clear in recent enforcement actions and warnings, in auto retail and other industries, that advertised prices must include all nonoptional costs to the consumer.
Read More →
Used Autos Supply Dwindles
The March shopping surge, despite high prices, cut into inventory by the most since the thick of the pandemic, Cox Automotive analysts calculated.
Read More →
Managing Risk Effectively Through Changing Times
The variables influencing risk pricing have changed significantly over the past five years. Being proactive and responsive to emerging trends is not optional but essential.
Read More →
Survey Reveals What Won't Fix What's Breaking Car Sales
AutoPayPlus says extra-long auto loans are trapping consumers and threatening the dealer trade-in cycle, and that the industry is leveraging the wrong tools to combat high MSRPs.
Read More →
