Buying Used Getting Unusually Expensive
Carfax research finds little difference in price from some models’ new units

The 2023 Honda Civic is priced close to its 2025 counterpart in Carfax's recent listings.
Honda
Used-vehicle prices are getting so high that some models are approaching new-car levels.
A Carfax study found that the average used-vehicle price has reached its highest point in a year and a half to nearly $25,000, or about $1,300 more.
The vehicle data and listings provider researched its listings from September and October to uncover the phenomenon. Limited used inventory is driving the price inflation, said Carfax, which indicated supply is still under prepandemic levels due to a drop in new-vehicle sales during the peak Covid period.
“It’s rare for used and new car values to be this close,” said Carfax Editor in Chief Patrick Olsen.
Though vehicles generally lose 40% of their value after three years of ownership, Carfax determined that some well-selling models’ 2023 units are listed at prices within about 10% of their new 2025 counterparts. They include the Honda Civic and the Ford Bronco, Kia Seltos and Toyota Corolla Cross SUVs.
Taking the Civic as an example, Carfax calculates that the average price of a 2023 unit is at $24,300, compared to $27,400 for a 2025 Civic, translating to just a $25 monthly payment difference for buyers making a 10% down payment and financing over 72 months.
The company said automakers and dealers are offering consumers financing deals to juice new-vehicle buying in the inflated economy.
More Industry

Dealer Debrief: New-Vehicle Sales Update
In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses the state of new-vehicle sales.
Read More →
Color Your Ride
The first vehicles by startup automaker Slate will come with the option of a medley of wraps in five colors familiar from your childhood.
Read More →
China Leads Global EV Sales
Globally, electric-vehicle sales are continuing their upward trajectory, buoyed by Chinese exports, as the North American region continues to lag behind.
Read More →
How Defection Data is Bridging the Dealership Conversion Gap
Lead volume is flat, cross-shopping is up and brand loyalty is in retreat. As confident sales teams keep losing buyers they thought they had, daily industry sales data is showing dealers exactly where their funnel is breaking and how to fix it without buying a single new lead.
Read More →
Optimized Charging Could Reduce Costs
According to an Alliance for Automotive Innovation analysis, optimized EV charging could cut costs for drivers and improve grid infrastructure - potential adoption incentives.
Read More →
June Automotive Boon?
A forecast for this month’s new-vehicle sales tells a familiar 2026 story: Year-over-year comparisons must be made in light of last year’s aberrations.
Read More →
Safety Improvements Save Lives
Over the past 30 years, automakers have made many safety tweaks to their vehicles. An insurance industry testing group says that's largely thanks to its crash-worthiness program and that prevented fatalities are the clear result.
Read More →
Indiana Dealership Changes Hands
The Chicago-area CDJR store has been in business for nearly 70 years and is now part of a fast-growing automotive group spread across six states.
Read More →
Survey Shows What Technicians Want
Data gathered by the ASE Training Managers Council shows that service technicians prefer classroom or instructor-led training and hands-on lab work over online or self-led training.
Read More →
Holman Opens New Lexus Dealership
Located in the heart of Clark County, Lexus of Vancouver features a multi-level showroom, more than 30 service bays, an indoor drive for drop-off and pick-up and a fleet of courtesy vehicles.
Read More →
