Buying Used Getting Unusually Expensive
Carfax research finds little difference in price from some models’ new units

The 2023 Honda Civic is priced close to its 2025 counterpart in Carfax's recent listings.
Honda
Used-vehicle prices are getting so high that some models are approaching new-car levels.
A Carfax study found that the average used-vehicle price has reached its highest point in a year and a half to nearly $25,000, or about $1,300 more.
The vehicle data and listings provider researched its listings from September and October to uncover the phenomenon. Limited used inventory is driving the price inflation, said Carfax, which indicated supply is still under prepandemic levels due to a drop in new-vehicle sales during the peak Covid period.
“It’s rare for used and new car values to be this close,” said Carfax Editor in Chief Patrick Olsen.
Though vehicles generally lose 40% of their value after three years of ownership, Carfax determined that some well-selling models’ 2023 units are listed at prices within about 10% of their new 2025 counterparts. They include the Honda Civic and the Ford Bronco, Kia Seltos and Toyota Corolla Cross SUVs.
Taking the Civic as an example, Carfax calculates that the average price of a 2023 unit is at $24,300, compared to $27,400 for a 2025 Civic, translating to just a $25 monthly payment difference for buyers making a 10% down payment and financing over 72 months.
The company said automakers and dealers are offering consumers financing deals to juice new-vehicle buying in the inflated economy.
More Industry

Kentucky Store Leaves Family
An auto group stretched across three states picked up the Lexington-area Ford fixture as its second store for the brand in the state.
Read More →
U.S. Auto Brands Falling Behind
Asian auto brands are outpacing U.S. brands in stateside new-vehicle sales. Learn more in this week's Dealer Debrief with Lauren!
Read More →
U.S. EV Market Update | Dealer Debrief
The U.S. electric vehicle market is slowly recovering from the loss of the federal EV tax credit last fall. Learn more in this week's Dealer Debrief!
Read More →
Auto Finance Numbers Set Records
Third-quarter data show how consumers are adapting to ongoing affordability challenges facing the new- and-used-vehicle markets.
Read More →
Auto Dealerships Can’t Afford to Ignore the 50+ Consumer
Younger generations may be all the buzz today when it comes to product marketing targets, but their older cohorts command a sizable share of purchasing power.
Read More →
Savings Seekers Boost U.S. Automakers’ Rivals
As consumers here look for ways to curb inflation’s affect on their budgets, brands offering plenty of alternative powertrains are closing in on home-grown OEMs.
Read More →
The Slow Electric Ascent
Second-quarter data show that the electric-vehicle market in the U.S. is inching up, the majority of states seeing a month-over-month increase.
Read More →
Safer Rides & Cyberattacks
Vehicle crash testing is getting a virtual boost, but auto dealerships are facing increased cyberattacks. Learn more in this week's Dealer Debrief!
Read More →
Affordability Angst | Dealer Debrief
August saw little relief for car buyers, whether they were shopping new or used. Take a look at the month's breakdown in this week's Dealer Debrief!
Read More →
Virtual Crash Testing in the Works
A company's platform works alongside physical crash testing to gather insights into occupant response and injury mechanisms, with the idea of helping automakers develop safer vehicles.
Read More →