auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The Long View

Hudson explains why the regulation of auto sales and finance is less like a battle and more like the Hundred Years War.

November 30, 2015
4 min to read


People think that the wave of federal and state regulation of the credit industry is something new. It ain’t so.

I gave a presentation a couple of weeks ago in which I tried to convey to the audience the historical sweep of the struggle between the U.S. consumer credit industry and the country’s pro-consumer protection advocates. The narrative I came up with reminded me of the Hundred Years’ War.

Ad Loading...

The first thing to note about The Hundred Years’ War is that it wasn’t. It lasted through a series of conflicts for 116 years — from 1337 to 1453. The fight, between the rulers of England and the rulers of France and their respective allies, was about who would control France.

The battle over the regulation of credit has not yet gone on for 100 years, much less 116 years, but it’s beginning to get a bit long in the tooth.

I’m sure that other credit scholars could identify earlier points at which the battle was joined, but I’ll pick the point after World War II, when the combination of returning soldiers, high demand for household formation (they had to put us “Boomer” babies somewhere) and suddenly idled industrial war capacity led to the increasing production of cars, washing machines, furniture and those “enormous” 12-inch-screen TV sets. The modern credit movement arguably can be traced to companies who rushed to make it possible for people to buy the things they needed and pay for them over time.

The regulation of credit law at the time was not exactly what you’d call robust. The Uniform Law Commission first promulgated the Uniform Commercial Code in 1952. (The effort began in 1942.) The UCC supplanted the Law Merchant, which was a system of rules and customs and usages generally recognized and adopted by traders as the law for the regulation of their commercial transactions and the resolution of their controversies. Neither the original UCC nor the Law Merchant was particularly long on consumer protection.

But someone always spoils the party, and it wasn’t long before creditors, including car dealers, behaved badly. Onerous credit terms, high finance charge rates, a mishmash of ways to calculate and disclose interest and finance charge rates, collection and repossession abuses and other sorts of misbehavior led to a wave of state laws regulating consumer lending and the credit sale of goods to consumers. These state laws were, for the most part, a mishmash of responses to the abuses emerging in the marketplace.

Ad Loading...

The uneven response of the states to consumer protection led the Uniform Law Commission to promulgate the Uniform Consumer Credit Code in 1968. The “U3C” was intended as a comprehensive regulation of consumer credit in any state which chose to enact it. Later issued in modified versions, the U3C was not exactly a flop, but it didn’t take the nation by storm, either. Today it, or parts of it, can be found in the laws of a double handful of states.

The same forces that propelled the development of the U3C were at work at the federal level as well. Sen. William Proxmire’s introduction of the Truth in Lending Act in the late ’60s was followed by a tidal wave of federal consumer credit regulation, including the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, the Fair Credit Reporting Act and the Consumer Leasing Act, to mention a few.

After the mid-’70s, things quieted down a bit. The industry actually scored a modest victory in 1980 with federal legislation that “simplified” the Truth in Lending Act. But the quiet was only a relative quiet — the consumer advocates pressed their agendas in other places, including before the drafting committees of the various articles of the Uniform Law Commissioners, trying to turn the UCC into a nationwide pro-consumer body of law.

But the consumer advocates went down in flames occasionally, as well. As an example, after several years of development, the Uniform Law Commissioners’ Uniform Consumer Leasing Act, a veritable Christmas tree on which the consumer advocates had hung every “gotcha” anti-lessor provision they could dream up, ended up being adopted only in one state.

The pendulum is never still, though, and now we have Dodd-Frank, the CFPB and Elizabeth Warren. The consumer advocates are pretty much in the driver’s seat at the moment, and many industry folks spend a lot of time railing about the “overregulation” of the credit industry.

Ad Loading...

No doubt the pendulum will eventually swing back in the other direction. After all, we’re only 60 years into this particular war.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Dealer Ops

Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 07/15/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Dealer Opsby Lauren LawrenceJuly 15, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Defection Data & EV Updates

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses how to use defection data to your advantage and the latest on EV sales and charging infrastructure.

Read More →
Two professionals shake hands while exchanging a car key fob beside a vehicle, symbolizing a vehicle sale, lease agreement, or dealership transaction.
SponsoredJuly 8, 2026

How Defection Data is Bridging the Dealership Conversion Gap

Lead volume is flat, cross-shopping is up and brand loyalty is in retreat. As confident sales teams keep losing buyers they thought they had, daily industry sales data is showing dealers exactly where their funnel is breaking and how to fix it without buying a single new lead.

Read More →
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 07/02/2026 with Lauren Lawrence
Dealer Opsby Lauren LawrenceJuly 2, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Where are you losing customers?

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses the hidden leaks in dealerships where you might be losing customers without even realizing it.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 06/25/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Dealer Opsby Lauren LawrenceJune 26, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Improving Your Inventory Management

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers a new survey that shows what service technicians really want and two launches that could help improve your inventory and vehicle life cycle management.

Read More →
group of people standing in a circle holding puzzle pieces together
Dealer OpsJune 1, 2026

Ladies and Gentlemen, This Is a Dealership: Why the Fundamentals Still Decide Who Wins

A teaching moment by a legendary football coach happens to apply perfectly in the auto retail space. Learn what it is and how to use it to your store’s advantage.

Read More →
Cover image for a BOK Financial report titled “Timing the market: How avoiding volatility entirely can hurt long-term reinsurance program performance.” The image shows several road construction barricades with flashing amber warning lights lined up in a nighttime work zone. Beneath the image, red text explains that avoiding volatility can mean falling behind inflation and missing market rebounds that drive long-term surplus growth. The BOK Financial logo appears at the bottom right.
SponsoredMay 8, 2026

What Market Timing Mistakes Mean for Your Reinsurance Program

When volatility hits, dealer-owned reinsurance programs face a familiar temptation: pull back and wait for calmer waters. New data from BOK Financial shows why that instinct can quietly cost you years of surplus growth.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
two cars on a billboard, No Hidden Fees
ComplianceMay 1, 2026

Dealer Ads and the FTC

The agency has made it clear in recent enforcement actions and warnings, in auto retail and other industries, that advertised prices must include all nonoptional costs to the consumer.

Read More →
Closeup of white car's headlight, front end
Dealer Opsby Hannah MitchellApril 17, 2026

Used Autos Supply Dwindles

The March shopping surge, despite high prices, cut into inventory by the most since the thick of the pandemic, Cox Automotive analysts calculated.

Read More →
hands making protective frame over red car, Risk Reality Check, Be Proactive, Auto Dealer Today logo
Dealer OpsApril 1, 2026

Managing Risk Effectively Through Changing Times

The variables influencing risk pricing have changed significantly over the past five years. Being proactive and responsive to emerging trends is not optional but essential.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Car key, stacks of coins, and a paper car cutout with AutoPayPlus logo, representing auto financing, loan terms, and vehicle affordability trends.
Dealer Opsby StaffMarch 31, 2026

Survey Reveals What Won't Fix What's Breaking Car Sales

AutoPayPlus says extra-long auto loans are trapping consumers and threatening the dealer trade-in cycle, and that the industry is leveraging the wrong tools to combat high MSRPs.

Read More →