auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Change Is Required

The automotive industry is going through rapid change, facing additional costs associated with personnel, benefits, and retention, and depending on a steady stream of additional customers to replace those customers that have defected. So how do you change how you conduct business to meet the current challenge?

by Leonard Buccholz
August 26, 2020
Change Is Required

The automotive industry is going through rapid change, facing additional costs associated with personnel, benefits, and retention, and depending on a steady stream of additional customers to replace those customers that have defected. So how do you change how you conduct business to meet the current challenge?

IMAGE: 3alexd via GettyImages.com

6 min to read


What’s the difference between the average dealership or repair facility during this current state of our country and say, ride-sharing services, like Uber and Lyft?

I’ll give you a minute to ponder that question. However, believe it or not, there are many similarities between the two industries.

Ad Loading...

Both industries are going through rapid change. Both are facing additional costs associated with personnel, benefits, and retention — personnel and customers. Both are dependent on a steady stream of additional customers to replace those customers that have defected. Both industries are being asked to change how they do business to meet the current challenge. 

Give up?

Nothing is different.

That’s right. The same conditions are plaguing both industries.

Easy to see the correlation now, isn’t it?

Ad Loading...

The virus is not our fault. It’s a worldwide problem. What is our fault is the way we’ve been doing business for some time, before the COVID-19 outbreak. 

We became survey hounds consumed by the pursuit of scores. We were concerned about issues only when it affected the dollars coming in, provided training to our personnel only when absolutely necessary, and when there were no other cheaper alternatives, constantly and consistently changed employees pay plans and benefits. We waited for our problems to be solved by technology, and over the past few years, happily existed in a world of our own making.

But, as the saying goes: “The chickens have come home to roost, Bobby Boucher.”

We are facing a crisis that demands change, and we cannot correct it doing the same old things. Let me give you an example. Most dealerships have attacked the current issues by changing the following: new hours, mining the recall lists, offering pickup and delivery, providing a vehicle cleaning service, prospecting from the SOP bin, changing pay plans and benefits, and laying off personnel.

When we finally get back to normal (if there ever will be a normal), we will need to immediately re-energize the customer base because — guess what — they realized they didn’t need us all that much.

Ad Loading...

Oh sure, recalls and goodwill are important, but will it be enough to get John Q. Public back into the dealership’s doors for regular service and maintenance? If you are counting on that to happen organically, I challenge you to start thinking differently.

Some dealers will throw money at customers, chase customer retention instead of building customer retention, keep reducing costs (by any means necessary), put training on the back burner, and expect technology to come to the rescue.

Here’s a little secret about technology: It does not work with untrained people.

So, if you’ve been waiting and looking around for help, and are expecting technology to save you, you might be disappointed with the results. It’s takes a trained professional using the latest technology to overcome this challenge in our industry. You can’t do it with just one of those things, you need both.

First, your dealer clients need to train the service sales team. Many of you have grown up in the car business and have been around many service departments and many service personnel. I dare say, if  personnel have been around awhile, you would think they would have had some training or instruction along the way.

Ad Loading...

Not the case.

I will bet everyone reading this, that I can go into any dealership in North America (or the world for that matter), and find an advisor or manager that has been in the business for years and years, and has never been trained, other than “Here is your phone, here is your desk, don’t mess it up.”

What does that make them?

It makes them survivors.

They escaped being eaten alive by this business, albeit, many of them are covered in “scars” from customer and management encounters over the years. But it doesn’t make them good advisors and managers, and years of the same experiences only keep them in the same crab bucket they started in.

Ad Loading...

You know about crab buckets, right?

Put a bunch of crabs in a bucket and you get crab mentality. Nobody gets out and they all suffer the same consequences. Much like the mentality permeating our industry today. We need to stop the crab mentality — get people out of the bucket and into a training program — or we are doomed like those crustaceans going to the boiling pot. That’s why you need to train continuously. 

Second, you need technology that makes sense, works right, and is easy to use. 

Take software. There are lots of software solutions out there and you can narrow down your choices by using three simple questions.

  1. Does the software help advisors sell and service more customers, and is it easy to learn and implement for the dealership team and customers? 

  2. Does the software help increase engagement, provide transparency and build relationships?

  3. Does the software help make a profit?

Ad Loading...

These three simple questions will guide you and narrow down the choices. Then it becomes a matter of selecting the one that is right for you. Keep in mind that the best choice might not always be the most obvious choice.

Not only should it be friendly to the customer (and the advisor), it needs to be robust, feature-rich, upgradeable, easy to make changes based on dealership preferences, provide reliable and instantaneous communications, and be accessible from any device, anywhere.

Why do we need it today?

Here are some recent survey results from different sources. AAA says that two out of three drivers don’t necessarily trust repair shops. According to DEM Automotive, dealers lose between 60-78% of revenue on cars that are three to six years old and approximately 80-92% on cars more than seven years old.

What will this same survey look like six months after the virus has been corralled and the industry has started to return to “normal”?

Ad Loading...

This is nothing new to many of you reading this article. We’ve been fighting the customer attrition problem for a long time.

But do you know what has not changed?

The experience we provide our customers.

Our customers are telling us we need to do something different. The industry is being turned upside-down by disruptors. Traditional sales and service methods are being washed away in favor of the convenience, speed, value, transparency, and trust model, and that requires us to change.

People make up our business, and they are telling us that the way we do business is not the way the they want it. They can choose their level of service and experience with the push of a few buttons.

Ad Loading...

Want a bigger rental car? Click.

Want a large instead of a small? Click.

Want to upgrade your hotel room? Click.

Want more legroom?

Click … Click … Click.

Ad Loading...

Options are what make the experience better, people are what makes the experience memorable. Give your customer options, train your personnel so well that they become the standard by which others emulate, provide your personnel with the tools necessary to engage and enhance the customer, and then get out of the way.

If you have not considered a training program for your advisors and fixed operations personnel and combined it with a communications and service sales software tool to change how you interact with your customers, then you might be part of the new dealership extinction event that’s coming to a town near you.

Leonard Buccholz is a trainer, consultant and lifetime learner. He has been a professional workshop and seminar facilitator with success as a leadership, sales process, communications and fixed operations coach.

Originally posted on Agent Entrepreneur

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Industry

Photo of Lexus of Warwick car dealership exterior
Industryby Hannah MitchellMarch 27, 2026

Lexus Dealership Changes Hands

The addition of a coveted brand, picked up from Penske Automotive, makes 15 total stores for a family-owned auto group in the Northeast.

Read More →
chart showing the quarterly electric vehicle market share from 2020-2025
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 27, 2026

EV Sales Slide While Hybrids Climb

California, as usual, led the country in EV registrations in the fourth quarter, but the U.S. as a whole saw a 43% year-over-year volume decrease.

Read More →
gray background with white text that says Dealer Debrief 03/25/2026 with Lauren Lawrence. picture of a white woman (Lauren) with red hair
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 25, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Safety, Supply & Partnership

In this week's Dealer Debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers a new safety assessment, current inventory issues, and a new payables process for dealerships.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
chart denoting a downward trend with a picture of a red electric vehicle and the Auto Dealer Today logo
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 19, 2026

2026 EV Sales Start Slow

Most U.S. automakers have experienced a decline in electric-vehicle sales as global and North American sales numbers have dropped year-over-year, according to Benchmark Mineral Intelligence.

Read More →
Auto Dealer Today Dealer Debrief 03/17/2026 with Lauren Lawrence
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 17, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Exports, Acquisitions & More

In this week's Dealer Debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers the top automotive exporter for 2025, a Tennessee dealership acquisition, and leadership changes for software and service provider KPA.

Read More →
red Mazda headlight/bumper, Raising the standard, Auto Dealer Today logo in white
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 13, 2026

Mazda Tops in New Safety Assessment

Consumer Reports’ new Safety Verdict ranks vehicles based on federal safety standards, as well as features it believes should be available to all consumers, such as blind-spot warnings.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of a parked Jeep Recon with a mountain peak in the background
Industryby Hannah MitchellMarch 13, 2026

February Auto Supply Out of Balance

Automakers and dealers have in some cases overstocked lower-demand tiers, though they demonstrated pricing discipline, according to Cox Automotive, which sees the need for greater inventory balance.

Read More →
headshot of Lauren Lawrence with Auto Dealer Today logo, Dealer Debrief, and date March 10, 2026
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 10, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Robots, Insurance Churn & More

In this week's Dealer Debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers AI-enhanced robots, auto insurance churn, and transparent dealership pricing.

Read More →
aerial view of BMW Spartangburg, South Carolina plant
Industryby Lauren LawrenceMarch 6, 2026

BMW Tops U.S. Exports

In 2025 over 400,000 BMW X models were assembled at the BMW plant in Spartanburg, S.C., which is the automaker’s only U.S.-based manufacturing factory.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Industryby StaffMarch 6, 2026

Explore the 12 Rules for an F&I Life at EFI

EFI 2026 will take place April 13–15 at The Cosmopolitan Las Vegas.

Read More →