auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Opinion: States Lead the Way in Privacy Law

Until a national privacy bill is adopted, auto dealers face a patchwork of standards written in places like California, Colorado, and Vermont — not to mention the European Union.

by Matt Dumiak
January 11, 2019
Opinion: States Lead the Way in Privacy Law

A recent rule change in Vermont requires data brokers to disclose the information they collect from consumers and allow them to opt out.

Photo by Thomas Pajot via Getty Images

3 min to read


Privacy regulations and legislation are topics that continue to be of concern for many auto dealers. News of data breaches, data vulnerabilities, and compromised private information is released almost daily from businesses both small and large.

No dealership is exempt from risk. The federal government has yet to propose a national privacy bill. Several states, including Virginia, Vermont, Colorado, and New Jersey, have introduced related privacy regulations recently.

Ad Loading...

California set themselves apart with the adoption of the California Consumer Privacy Act, which gave citizens the rights to not only protect their own data, but to obligate businesses to disclose exactly which information has been collected about them.

Vermont recently implemented a law regulating data broker companies that buy and sell personal information. Brokers must now disclose what information they collect as well as allow customers to opt out of collection. Furthermore, consumers can sue data brokers if they sell any information that causes illegal discrimination.

A similar law proposed in Colorado is somewhat broader yet specifically manages personal identifying information. Individual states seem to be leading the way for data privacy regulation discussions. For dealers who purchase consumer information, this should be of concern.

International regulations have also played a significant role in the privacy discussion, specifically following enforcement of the European Union’s General Data Privacy Regulation.

These regulations have certainly contributed to the movement towards consumerism and prompted dealers in the United States to rethink data collection and management, considering how violating these regulations could adversely affect their business and brand. Many dealers are asking themselves, “Am I liable and governed by the legislation in the EU?” For many, the answer is yes.

Ad Loading...

Since the introduction of the CCPA, several U.S. senators have proposed policy options for national legislation on data security and privacy. Proposed bills have had a GDPR-like flavor that is similar in scope to the international regulation. If the U.S. were to adopt similar regulatory standards, dealerships that handle personal data would need to build systems that include data protection by design and default.

Regardless of dealership size, the magnitude of data collected, shared or mismanaged is more concerning considering the sensitivity of private information dealerships are entrusted to protect. As the conversation around regulation increases, there has been much talk about what a national privacy law might look like — and how state regulations would affect dealers doing business across the U.S.

At the forefront of privacy-related issues are very visible and widely used “big tech” providers. These big companies have demonstrated some interest in getting ahead of new regulations by drafting and proposing regulatory standards themselves — possibly because there is a monetary desire for bills written on their terms, rather than abiding by laws passed in Washington.

In conclusion, states will likely continue to pave the way for privacy regulations. Until formal national legislation is adopted, and voters see these initiatives on their ballots, states will continue to implement their own forms of data protection. Problems will continue to rise for businesses as states implement their own laws that non-regulated states must abide by. A national privacy law could make this transition easier.

Matt Dumiak is director of privacy services, customer engagement compliance at CompliancePoint, where he is focused on U.S. and international direct marketing compliance regulations. Contact him at matt.dumiak@bobit.com.

Originally posted on F&I and Showroom

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Compliance

Product & Technologyby StaffFebruary 4, 2026

AAMS Training and Mosaic Compliance Services Merge

The strategic combination is intended to expand technology-driven compliance solutions for the automotive industry.

Read More →
ComplianceOctober 6, 2025

The Jurisprudence of Pricing

Legal concept helps makes sense of California’s recently passed version of the failed federal CARS legislation.

Read More →
Digitalby Hannah MitchellSeptember 5, 2025

Cyber Threats Continue Apace

Hackers, seeing auto retail vulnerabilities in 2024 CDK incident, are taking advantage, data show.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
IndustryJuly 17, 2025

Trump 2.0 and Enforcement Priorities

The upshot is don’t relax, because regulation indeed continues.

Read More →
Blue and white Automotive Service Professionals logo presented over a blue background with various wrench tools.
Complianceby StaffJune 11, 2025

June Is Automotive Service Professionals Month

Observance is opportunity to thank technicians for their crucial role in auto retail.

Read More →
DigitalJune 9, 2025

The Real ID Deadline

Challenges auto dealers may still face verifying identities

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Complianceby StaffApril 28, 2025

Law Firms Tops in Auto Work

They bested all others on value or volume in the first quarter on major deals.

Read More →
Complianceby StaffJanuary 30, 2025

Cox Automotive Releases Compliance Guide

New edition walks auto dealers through relevant regulations for 2025.

Read More →
ComplianceJanuary 1, 2025

Safeguarding Customer Data

Encryption serves a critical role in automotive retail today.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Complianceby StaffDecember 24, 2024

Trump 2.0 and Retail Automotive

Administration’s plans should generally bode well for the industry.

Read More →