Your Daily Operations Magazine
Search Close Menu

Dealer Ops

Dealer's Mail Campaign Results In $250,000 Settlement

Some legal principles are so simple. Like the one that says if you hire someone to do a job for you and they screw something up, you end up paying the price. Or the one that says “don’t get your legal advice from your vendors.”

A recent issue of Automotive News carried an article about a Minnesota dealership that agreed to pay a $250,000 fine to settle a case brought against it by the Minnesota Attorney General. That’s right – 250 “large.” The AG (“AG” stands for “aspiring governor”) was upset, it seems, about a mail campaign that the dealership had employed.

The AG’s press release was not exactly crammed with detail, so it’s not precisely clear what it was in the mail campaign that got the AG’s shorts in a knot. There seemed to be a couple of major, identifiable problems, however.
It seems the mail campaign targeted consumers who had filed for bankruptcy without first getting the consumers’ permission. The AG also claimed that the mailing materials were designed to look as if they had been mailed by the U.S. Bankruptcy Court and were “guaranteed” by the state of Minnesota.

The article quotes the dealer’s lawyer as stating that the dealer “relied on a third-party vendor that represented to us that the mailer did meet with all the applicable statutes and regulations.” You wonder if the vendor’s representations were in writing. You also wonder if the dealer’s contract with the vendor provided that if the vendor’s representations concerning the legality of the mailing program were false, the vendor would indemnify the dealer if the dealer suffered as a result of the falsity. Finally, you wonder if the dealer, or the dealer’s lawyer, did any due diligence on the vendor to determine whether the vendor was sufficiently solvent to make its representations and contractual undertakings worth anything.

You would like to feel sorry for this dealer, but personally can’t muster a lot of sympathy. Remember that this mail program went out in the dealership’s name, so, at the end of the day, it is the dealer’s responsibility to determine whether the mail program is legal or not. This dealer says he abdicated this responsibility to the mail house. Rather than do its homework and take responsibility for the legal content of the mailing program conducted in its name, the dealer took the business gamble that the mail house knew what it was doing.

Another reason I can’t rouse up any sympathy for the dealer is that the mailing materials shouldn’t have passed the dealer’s “smell test.” Whether the materials were legal or not, using materials that looked like checks and that were designed to give a false impression about their origin just isn’t straightforward marketing.

You can call me a stickler if you want, but I’ve still got my $250,000. Oh well, maybe the dealer’s insurance policy covers liability arising out of advertising campaigns.



Number of EVs to Double by 2021

U.S. electric-vehicle sales forecasted by the Edison Electric Institute would require the...

The number of electric vehicles on U.S. roads will double in the next three years, according to a new report from the Edison Electric Institute.


AutoSource Names Brad Walsh CEO

Bradley J. Walsh has been hired as the new CEO of AutoSource, succeeding founder Luke Kjar as chief executive of the Utah-based branded title dealer group.


Used Cars Add to Hot Streak

Subcompact cars such as the Honda Fit enjoyed a 0.6% increase in average retained values in...

Black Book’s November Used Vehicle Retention Index finds value and demand have pushed pre-owned prices skyward for the seventh month in a row.


Waymo Rolls Out Self-Driving Taxis

Self-driving, revenue-generating taxis have officially hit the streets of Chandler, Ariz., and...

Waymo has set a new standard for driverless-vehicle proponents and ride-hailing providers by launching Waymo One, a revenue-generating autonomous transportation service.

Dealer Job Finder

See more


2020 Jeep Gladiator

Pricing has yet to be announced for the 2020 Jeep Gladiator, a new vehicle that promises...

Chrysler unveiled the all-new Jeep Gladiator at the Los Angeles Auto Show in late November. Billed as “the most capable midsize truck ever,” the new vehicle marks Jeep’s return to the pickup ranks for the first time since the Comanche ended its production run in the 1992-MY. The Gladiator is due in showrooms in the second quarter of 2019.


Cars Outpace Trucks in Lost Value

Pre-owned full-size cars such as the Chrysler 300 depreciated by an average of 0.77% in Black...

Black Book’s latest Market Insights Report finds used cars continue to depreciate faster than light trucks, but strong incentives for new cars indicate sustained demand for some types.