Your Daily Operations Magazine
Search Close Menu

Dealer Ops

Why You Shouldn't Delay Your Red Flags Program

The Red Flags Rule, announced by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in November of 2007, had a mandatory effective date of November 1, 2008. On October 22, 2008, the FTC announced that it would suspend enforcement of the Rule until May 1, 2009. The October 22 announcement gives financial institutions and creditors subject to the FTC's jurisdiction (that means car dealers) an additional six months to get their Red Flags programs in place without incurring FTC sanctions.

“Hooray!” you say. It’s hard to disagree with the additional breathing room, but the additional time won’t do you any good unless you get to work on your program now.

From our vantage point, the vast majority of dealers would not have had a complying Red Flags program in place by November 1, and that was after they had been given nearly a year to put the program in place.

We are urging dealers to move with urgency to get their Red Flags programs in place quickly—long before the end of this 6-month enforcement grace period granted by the FTC. Why? Three reasons, and they may apply to you.

If you procrastinated before, you’ll do it again. If your dealership didn’t have a program in place with a year’s notice of the mandatory effective date, what is going to change? We think it’s likely those dealers with a bad case of procrastination aren’t going to be magically cured by the FTC’s medicine of additional time.

There may still be risk in not having a program. The FTC has announced that it won’t prosecute violators for six months, but there’s an argument that the Rule is mandatorily effective now, notwithstanding the FTC’s statement that it will forego enforcement. Think about it like this – your town lowers the speed limit on the main drag, but the cops announce they won’t hand out speeding tickets for less than the old limit for a couple of months, so people can adjust to the new limit. The announcement by the cops about how they will enforce the new limit won’t stop a plaintiffs’ lawyer from suing if someone exceeds the new limit and causes injuries or damages.

Look for those lawyers who make their livings suing dealerships to argue that the federal requirement is in force notwithstanding the FTC’s enforcement policy, and that the dealer’s failure to comply with the federal requirement constitutes an unfair or deceptive act or practice under state law. Lest you think such a “bootstrapping” attack is far-fetched, we’ve seen just this argument in connection with federal odometer law claims.

It’s good for you! Finally, the Red Flags Rule is a bit unusual, in that its principal effect will be to benefit the dealer by making identity theft more difficult. If an identity thief strikes your dealership, it’s hard to imagine a situation in which the dealer doesn’t end up with the resulting loss. That being the case, why wouldn’t you rush to get your program in place?

There you are, three reasons. Get to work!

Vol 5, Issue 12



Number of EVs to Double by 2021

U.S. electric-vehicle sales forecasted by the Edison Electric Institute would require the...

The number of electric vehicles on U.S. roads will double in the next three years, according to a new report from the Edison Electric Institute.


AutoSource Names Brad Walsh CEO

Bradley J. Walsh has been hired as the new CEO of AutoSource, succeeding founder Luke Kjar as chief executive of the Utah-based branded title dealer group.


Used Cars Add to Hot Streak

Subcompact cars such as the Honda Fit enjoyed a 0.6% increase in average retained values in...

Black Book’s November Used Vehicle Retention Index finds value and demand have pushed pre-owned prices skyward for the seventh month in a row.


Waymo Rolls Out Self-Driving Taxis

Self-driving, revenue-generating taxis have officially hit the streets of Chandler, Ariz., and...

Waymo has set a new standard for driverless-vehicle proponents and ride-hailing providers by launching Waymo One, a revenue-generating autonomous transportation service.

Dealer Job Finder

See more


2020 Jeep Gladiator

Pricing has yet to be announced for the 2020 Jeep Gladiator, a new vehicle that promises...

Chrysler unveiled the all-new Jeep Gladiator at the Los Angeles Auto Show in late November. Billed as “the most capable midsize truck ever,” the new vehicle marks Jeep’s return to the pickup ranks for the first time since the Comanche ended its production run in the 1992-MY. The Gladiator is due in showrooms in the second quarter of 2019.


Cars Outpace Trucks in Lost Value

Pre-owned full-size cars such as the Chrysler 300 depreciated by an average of 0.77% in Black...

Black Book’s latest Market Insights Report finds used cars continue to depreciate faster than light trucks, but strong incentives for new cars indicate sustained demand for some types.