Judge Allows Antitrust Lawsuit Against CARFAX to Proceed
The antitrust suit filed by more than 750 dealers against Carfax is now headed into discovery after a federal judge denied Carfax's motion to dismiss the case.
MINEOLA, N.Y. — This week, A federal judge denied a motion filed by CARFAX to dismiss a $350 million antitrust lawsuit brought against the provider of vehicle history reports by more than 750 dealerships. The case, filed by Bellavia Blat on behalf of the dealers in April 2013, is being heard in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
With the ruling, the case is now headed into the discovery phase. The lawsuit alleges that Carfax has forged illegal alliances with key players in the auto industry, freezing out competition and forcing dealers to pay higher prices for unreliable vehicle history reports. The suit notes that Carfax then uses its inflated revenues on ads that disparage dealers as dishonest.
“This recent decision is a substantial victory for the dealers, as the court held that we have asserted legally cognizable claims under the various antitrust laws,” said Bellavia Blatt Senior Partner Leonard A. Bellavia, which is seeking substantial money damages per dealership and an injunction against the alleged illegal conduct. “This is an important initiative to redress wrongs being committed against both dealers and consumers.”
Carfax declined to comment on the federal court's decision.
More Digital

Dealer Debrief: New Technician Credential & Vehicles for Change
In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers a new ADAS technician credential that is in the works and a partnership between NADA and Vehicles for Change.
Read More →
Dealer Debrief: Dealer's Choice Awards
In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers reinsurance, IIHS safety picks, and voting for the 2026 Dealers' Choice Awards.
Read More →
JD Power Launches F&I Performance, ID Verification Tools
The resources are the first two offerings by the company's new Dealer Solutions division, which is being led by auto industry veteran Doug Betts.
Read More →
Advanced Safety Features Make a Difference
GM says research shows such technologies have made real inroads in reducing the rate of U.S. collisions as it aims for crash-free roads.
Read More →
Cox Automotive to Acquire Fullpath
The company says the deal brings artificial intelligence-native data and marketing infrastructure to its dealer network for a unified platform.
Read More →
Managing Risk Effectively Through Changing Times
The variables influencing risk pricing have changed significantly over the past five years. Being proactive and responsive to emerging trends is not optional but essential.
Read More →
Dealer Debrief: EV Sales, Brand Loyalty & More
In this week's Dealer Debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers EV sales, tire brand loyalty, and new industry executive leaders.
Read More →
Reynolds, Corpay Partner to Enhance Dealership Payables
The new connection between the companies is designed to help digitize payments, targeting smoother transactions for automotive dealers.
Read More →
Owner Retention Stakes Have Never Been Higher
Service advisers represent dealerships’ foundation in fostering ongoing customer loyalty, and they must maintain certain standards to keep that foundation strong.
Read More →
Free Public Scoring System Rewards Honest Dealer Prices
CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index is based on verified quotes, and retailers can be rewarded with badges and other marketable proofs of honest pricing.
Read More →