auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Why Dealership Staff Fear Digital Retailing (and What to Do About It)

Dealers see the potential for more sales, higher profits, and improved CSI scores that digital sales and F&I can bring. Your employees fear the loss of job security and the burden of new responsibilities.

by Mike Cavanaugh
September 23, 2019
Why Dealership Staff Fear Digital Retailing (and What to Do About It)

Resistance is heightened when the outcome is uncertain.

Photo by Jonny Lindner via Pixabay

5 min to read


The benefits of digital retailing are many: happier customers, more confident salespeople, bigger profits. And yet many dealers struggle to implement digital retailing. The big hurdle is employee adoption. Dealership employees across all levels are reluctant to change.

It’s a major problem. You are making a substantial investment. You need your team members onboard because they are the ones engaging with customers day-to-day.

Ad Loading...

When digital retailing isn’t fully embraced or successfully implemented, you can end up with the opposite effect — losing sales and customers instead of gaining them.

Why Employees Resist Digitizing

Before we get to a solution, it’s important to recognize the reasons dealership staff are hesitant to adopt digital retailing.

One more system to log into: Staff already must log into a minimum of three systems every day — your CRM, your DMS, and your inventory management system. CRM adoption is already a pain point for dealers. If your staff can’t use the CRM, why add another system?

Adding to job security fears is the rising success of companies like Carvana, which sold more than 90,000 cars in 2018 without a single salesperson.

Ad Loading...

Loss of control: High-performing salespeople have years of experience and have perfected their own style and process. As the saying goes, “If ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” If salespeople, who often have an entrepreneurial mindset, are forced into a more rigid process, they can feel like their way of doing things is being taken away.

• Job security: Employees in many sectors share a common fear that technology will phase them out. Car salespeople may believe that if digital retailing works well, their job will be obsolete. “If a customer can buy a car online, why do they need me? I don’t want (or know how) to do anything else.”

TheCarvana effect: Adding to job security fears is the rising success of companies like Carvana, which sold more than 90,000 cars in 2018 without a single salesperson. Their entire process is done online. Motivated by this fear, staff may even find ways to sabotage digital retailing.

Read: Carvana Crashes Used-Vehicle Dealer Rankings

Fear of being micromanaged: With digital retailing, leadership can gain more data and insight into specific components of the sale and how well individual employees perform. People don’t like to feel like big brother is watching. In addition, salespeople may feel like the “art of the sale” is becoming the “science of the sale.”

Ad Loading...

Change is hard: No one likes change. People will hold onto the status quo, even at their own demise. To change, we need either fear or motivation. Leadership has plenty of fear and motivation with decreased margins and the potential to sell more cars less expensively. But what’s in it for the staff? Dealership staff may see only the negatives of digital retailing.

How to Get Employees Over the Hurdle

Dealer leadership, together with the digital retailing vendor, must partner to overcome these roadblocks. Here’s how:

Get buy-in. Make the decision process inclusive of everyone: salespeople, F&I managers, the GM, and sales and desk managers. Share the vision for the dealership and ask employees what they think. Discuss specific, desired outcomes, such as improving your CSI score from 4.5 to 4.9 or reducing your average transaction time by half.

What’s in it for me? Leadership and the vendor must clearly communicate how digital retailing will help employees be more successful. Here are some examples that motivate staff:

Ad Loading...
  • “Today you’re selling 10 cars a month. This can help you sell 20.”

  • “What would your income look like if you sold 50% more cars?”

  • “If you could prepare a deal in one hour instead of three, how many more customers could you take care of?”

  • “When customers have a better experience, they buy more often and tell their friends.”

  • “More consistency will lead to better satisfaction. More satisfaction equals more referrals.”

“Pull,” don’t “push.” When you “push” something, staff may do the bare minimum and even find ways to make the program fail. Instead, you want “pull” with staff recognizing what’s in it for them and telling leadership, “I want this, I need this.”

Read: Top 5 Ways to Increase Profitability Storewide

Start with a few champions and let it spread. Ask for two or three volunteers to be program “champions.” See how well it works for them by tracking specific success metrics — including transaction time, gross profit, and CSI scores — over 90 days. After seeing their success, more and more people will want to become part of it.

Train, train, train. Digital retailing is not a “set it and forget it.” It’s not a website widget. Consistent training must be part of the process to ensure constant improvement. Rely on your vendor, the experts of the product, to train your team. Insist on a minimum of two training sessions a month.

Ad Loading...

Document and share success stories. Use data to show how the program is really working. At least monthly, but ideally weekly, highlight success stories from your digital retailing program. If a salesperson has a record month, highlight it. Pull up a stellar customer review on the screen.

If it doesn’t help you sell more cars, or make more money, it will just be a distraction.

For dealership groups, share these stories across multiple rooftops. More stores will want to get in on the action. Remember, if it doesn’t help you sell more cars, or make more money, it will just be a distraction.

Five years ago, not a single car was purchased online. Now hundreds of thousands of people buy cars online. What will the auto retail industry look like in another five years?

To compete and survive in the coming years, dealerships need to invest in their people and digital platform. By alleviating the fears around digital retailing, you’ll not only get your people excited about the direction of the dealership and the industry, you’ll end up with the best outcome possible — more cars sold, a better customer experience, and more profits.

Ad Loading...

Mike Cavanaugh is executive vice president of MAX Digital.

Read: 5 Steps to Bring Your Dealer Website Up to Code

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Digital

Scott Worthington, vice president of product management at Reynolds and Reynolds, stands indoors in front of large windows wearing a navy blazer and white shirt.
Digitalby StaffMarch 3, 2026

Reynolds, Corpay Partner to Enhance Dealership Payables

The new connection between the companies is designed to help digitize payments, targeting smoother transactions for automotive dealers.

Read More →
mechanic filling out clipboard while inspecting under hood of vehicle
DigitalMarch 1, 2026

Owner Retention Stakes Have Never Been Higher

Service advisers represent dealerships’ foundation in fostering ongoing customer loyalty, and they must maintain certain standards to keep that foundation strong.

Read More →
Headshot of Zach Shefska, CEO of CarEdge, alongside the CarEdge logo on a blue background.
Digitalby StaffFebruary 24, 2026

Free Public Scoring System Rewards Honest Dealer Prices

CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index is based on verified quotes, and retailers can be rewarded with badges and other marketable proofs of honest pricing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic promoting StoneEagle at the 2026 NADA Show in Las Vegas, featuring a photo of CEO Cindy Allen.
Product & Technologyby StaffJanuary 20, 2026

StoneEagle to Unveil Next-Gen F&I Solutions at NADA

Empowering the F&I office through data is central to the company’s reimagined solutions it's scheduled to debut soon.

Read More →
Digitalby Hannah MitchellJanuary 9, 2026

Automaker Websites Valuable Tools

The majority of shoppers visit them, and most undecided consumers consider the brands whose sites they peruse, but some automakers emphasize brand over product detail.

Read More →
Product & Technologyby Hannah MitchellNovember 25, 2025

AI-Guided Car-Shopping Insight

Consumers say they’re using the tech, but many still end up at dealerships to seal the deal.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A smartphone displaying a Hertz Car Sales online listing sits beside the Cox Automotive logo, illustrating Cox’s new omnichannel car-buying platform.
Digitalby StaffNovember 11, 2025

Omnichannel Car-Buying Platform Launches

Cox Automotive says the technology enables online transactions on client sites and third-party marketplaces simultaneously.

Read More →
Digitalby Hannah MitchellOctober 31, 2025

Audi Drivers Can Ditch That Pesky Manual

Updated mobile app features AI assistant for tech questions, EV tasks and more

Read More →
Digitalby Hannah MitchellOctober 24, 2025

GM Cars to Get Smarter Over Time

Automaker announces single vehicle computing system to connect lineup for faster updates

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Shawn Concannon, president of TSD Mobility Solutions, stands inside a modern office building, representing TSD’s continued growth in connected-fleet technology.
Digitalby StaffOctober 14, 2025

TSD Mobility Acquisition to Bolster Telematics

Latest addition expands connected-fleet technology, strengthening telematics capabilities and global reach

Read More →