auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Data Mining: The Golden Opportunity You’re Ignoring

Why wait for slow times to mine your database? Expert offers a four-step plan to make data mining a full-time profit center — and all you need is a process and a champion.

by Winston Harrell
December 2, 2019
Data Mining: The Golden Opportunity You’re Ignoring

Most dealers mine their customer database when sales slow. Smart dealers prevent slowdowns by data mining full-time.

Photo by Rawf8 via GettyImages.com

6 min to read


It’s a good bet you’ve heard the following: “You have a 15% chance of selling to a new customer, but a 65% chance of selling to an existing one.” And chances are your dealership is capable of accessing today’s advanced data mining solutions, which do much of the heavy lifting by probing your database for sold and unsold buyers, customers in an equity position, service history and activity, website behavior, and more.

You set the criteria, and these solutions serve up the opportunities. It’s what happens next that causes dealers to lose faith in the promise of data mining.

Ad Loading...

The missing link for most dealers is a defined process that’s written down, implemented, and managed. Even without a process, data mining can generate 21% to 26% of your dealership’s monthly business.

With a proven process — and a point person — data mining won’t be something you do only when there’s a slowdown in sales. Here’s how it’s done, in four steps:

Read: CTV Advertising: What’s in It for Auto Dealers?

Step 1: Manage the Pipeline.

Done correctly, data mining should reduce your ad budget, especially when it comes to third-party lead providers. Think about it: Factor in the cost of digital marketing as well as print, radio, and television advertising, which you’re still going to want to do in some fashion. Add it all up, and you’re looking at a cost per lead of $300 to more than $1,000.

Ad Loading...

If you wrap your data mining efforts around a process overseen by a dedicated BDC manager, you can expect your cost per lead to drop below $100. And part of a dedicated manager’s duty is to run those CRM reports to make sure your dealership didn’t initiate contact with a lead for which your lead provider wants to take credit. That individual can then apply for a loan with that lead provider by sending over that list with the date and time your dealership reached out to those customers.

The author recommends putting your BDC manager in charge of you data mining phone and email campaign.

Photo by Violeta Stoimenova via GettyImages.com

Why do you need a dedicated individual to oversee your data mining process? Because the system is going to identify potential buyers who need to be contacted immediately.

You need someone to champion those opportunities — a job that might overwhelm the typical salesperson. Hey, your salespeople have plenty of phone and floor ups to handle, demos to conduct, offers and deliveries to make, customers to follow up with, and calls that need to be made to unsold customers.

Step 2: Tell, Don’t Sell.

Phone training is imperative. Without those skills, the effectiveness of outbound calls drops dramatically. First and foremost, those calls need to center around the customer, not your need to sell a car.

Ad Loading...

Additionally, your scripts shouldn’t be too involved or specific. It can be as simple as “I noticed you’ve owned your car for X period of time. With current factory incentives and rebates, I can probably get you into a new car at the same payment.”

Finally, make sure you base your scripts on current events. For instance, you can say:

“Hi, this is Winston. I hope I’m not interrupting anything important. I’m sure you have seen the news about the current trade wars and tariffs. This has had some effect on the used car market. One positive result for you is it has dramatically increased the value of used cars. Would it be OK if we made you a cash offer on your car?”

Read: 3 Reasons Smartphones Are the Secret to Service Success

Step 3: Manage the Campaign.

Ad Loading...

Your data mining initiative will not succeed on phone calls alone. Look for a data mining solution that facilitates email campaigns, and be sure to include a link to a webpage that reinforces the message contained in those emails. The message can outline a new opportunity or OEM program, for example, and your landing page can provide more in-depth details.

For lease customers, the email can start with:

“This is a friendly reminder that your lease is set to expire in six months. Following are the things you can expect during your lease return.” Then, “By the way, there is a Platinum Program available that’s designed to help you get out of your lease early. For more information, click on the link below.” The landing page can then open with the following: “Congratulations! You qualify for this program.”

Yes, someone has to build those pages. But a link to your homepage will be far less compelling.

Step 4: Focus on Fixed Ops.

Ad Loading...

Committing to the process I’ve outlined can also drive service business. But you will need your BDC to drive those activities. Your service advisors don’t have time. And by letting customers know it’s time for an oil change or that it has been more than a year since their last visit, you’ll be able to keep both your service and sales records current.

One person who will love your data mining tool’s service appointment feature is your used car manager. They will be sure to check the day’s service appointments, which, depending on the data mining system you use, should also list the value of the vehicles coming in for service.

Your car is on my buy list. When you get here, do you mind if my used car manager looks at it and makes an offer?

Trust me, that’s an easy call to make. It might go something like this:

“Hi, this is Winston with ABC Motors. I’m calling to confirm your service appointment tomorrow at 10 a.m.” The customer will respond with a “Yes,” which allows you to transition to the following: “While you’re here, did you need transportation anywhere?”

Ad Loading...

Again, everything you’ve said to this point benefits the customer, which sets up the following:

“I just noticed something. Your car is on my buy list. When you get here, do you mind if my used car manager looks at it and makes an offer?”

If you don’t get a bite, you want to mention a program that might get the customer to consider the offer. “As long as your credit hasn’t changed, I can probably get you into a new car and lower your payment by $10 to $20, or $40 to $50.” That’s my second run, and you always want to take two runs at everything.

Now, the person you select to champion your data mining process doesn’t necessarily need to be a BDC manager. It just needs to be a person who has a clear and pleasant voice and can think on their feet. And if this person is making calls, they will need to deliver the script without sounding like they’re reading from one. Voice inflections and the ability to go off and back on script are critical because the script is just a roadmap to where you need to go.

Winston Harrell is a 33-year industry veteran who serves as a strategic growth manager for users of DealerSocket’s RevenueRadar data mining tool.

Ad Loading...
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Digital

Headshot photo of Cox Automotive executive Derek Hansen
Digitalby StaffJune 22, 2026

Cox Automotive Tool to Streamline Dealership Workflows

The new Navigator offering is designed to work for dealers across the company's technology solutions for time savings and more.

Read More →
Photo of computer keyboard with a inkpen resting in front of it on the top of a desk
Digitalby StaffJune 22, 2026

DAS Technology Earns Multiple Industry Honors

The company's Power AI Search was recognized for automotive artificial intelligence as .

Read More →
Modern Data Strategy infographic
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceJune 19, 2026

Reduce Fragmentation, Connect Customer Data

Automotive dealerships have the opportunity to reach more consumers by putting their customer data into a unified system, according to a new report.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 06/18/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceJune 18, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Service Tech Recognition

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers a change to Automotive Service Professionals Month, a dealership acquisition, and a new Lexus rooftop!

Read More →
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 06/11/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceJune 15, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Manufacturing Meets Demand

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers shifting strategies in the U.S. auto industry and how they reflect the current consumer demand.

Read More →
Photo of red Tesla car parked outside of building
Digitalby Hannah MitchellJune 12, 2026

Trust of Autonomous Cars Not Automatic

A poll of U.S. consumers finds more awareness of the technology but no movement when it comes to relying on it for transportation.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 06/04/2026 with Lauren Lawrence
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceJune 4, 2026

Dealer Debrief: New Technician Credential & Vehicles for Change

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers a new ADAS technician credential that is in the works and a partnership between NADA and Vehicles for Change.

Read More →
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 05/28/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceMay 28, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Dealer's Choice Awards

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers reinsurance, IIHS safety picks, and voting for the 2026 Dealers' Choice Awards.

Read More →
Man smiling at camera.
Digitalby StaffMay 18, 2026

JD Power Launches F&I Performance, ID Verification Tools

The resources are the first two offerings by the company's new Dealer Solutions division, which is being led by auto industry veteran Doug Betts.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of Buick Envista moving down road flanked by trees
Digitalby Hannah MitchellMay 8, 2026

Advanced Safety Features Make a Difference

GM says research shows such technologies have made real inroads in reducing the rate of U.S. collisions as it aims for crash-free roads.

Read More →