auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Is Your Ad Strategy a Clunker?

Todd Swickard - Since the world is changing, your marketing strategy needs to change too, or you’ll be left in the dust. It’s time to trade in your old ways of doing things to get the most mileage out of your marketing budget. So, here are a few tips for how to go about reviewing your strategy to make sure it’s ready to roll.

November 6, 2009
4 min to read



Since the world is changing, your marketing strategy needs to change too, or you’ll be left in the dust. It’s time to trade in your old ways of doing things to get the most mileage out of your marketing budget. So, here are a few tips for how to go about reviewing your strategy to make sure it’s ready to roll.

Goals and Objectives of the Campaign
First, look at your goals. Are you trying to get more leads or more phone calls? Do you want to push used or new vehicles on your Web site? Are you looking to get more calls to service? Is the goal to rely more heavily on your Web site as your main lead source? Keep in mind that  your campaign will need to be adjusted to fit your goals.

Ensuring Proper Tracking of Results
Are you tracking your results? What are you tracking? You need to determine where the rubber meets the road. Even though overall sales are probably your main focus, the steps toward that goal are what you need to pay attention to. This means your leads. How many people are visiting your site? Where are they landing? Where are they coming from? Can you tell if they’ve come there from a print ad, pay-per-click (PPC) campaign or direct mailer? If not, you’ll want to revise your approach to include methods to track this. That way, you’ll know what’s working and what’s not.

Another factor in your tracking is frequency. Are you simply conducting monthly reviews? Why not check every week? Online marketing can be adjusted quickly, so you can make revisions to get the most bang for your buck.

Budgeting That Matches Your Needs
It’s standard  to apply no less than 10 percent of your total ad budget to online advertising, but many dealers have increased that amount to be equal to or above their traditional advertising. You’ll need to figure out what works for your dealership and find the right balance. Just like back in the day (five years ago?) when it was tough to find the sweet spot between radio, TV and newspapers, now you need to get the balance right between online and offline media. Tracking results will help determine where to up your spending, and where you can cut back.

Market Competitiveness
How competitive the market is can make a difference to your strategy. If you’re in a highly competitive market, you’ll probably need to up your overall spending, and you’ll need to spend more time paying attention to your tracking to see where your break-through is most effective.

I recommend that you perform a search yourself, using key words that you think people are likely to use (example: your make and city), and see what you get. If there are a lot of dealers or third-party lead providers on the page, you’ll know that you’re going to need to adjust your online budget up because it’s going to be more expensive to rank for the keywords you need. The fun part is that, by focusing money on search, you can sometimes – depending upon brand name recognition of your competitors – steal the leads their offline marketing has generated.

Don’t despair if your advertising budget won’t allow you to do everything you want. Select the tactics you want to start with, and replace the ones that aren’t performing as you go. Also, remember that for some tactics – like PPC advertising – you can do at a dialed-down budget, so you can still participate and achieve positive ROI and sales/leads. You won’t achieve full (100 percent) exposure on all of your keywords within the campaign that way; your ads will be dispersed throughout the day as evenly as the search engines can space them out based upon your spend. But you’ll be out there so people searching can be directed to your site.

Be realistic. Remember that every tactic has its own timeframe. While you’ll want to monitor on a weekly basis, don’t be too quick to toss out a tactic entirely. When a tactic isn’t consistently  providing results, that’s when to shift gears.

My last piece of advice: Remember that the total number of leads is not the same as the total number of qualified leads. Make sure you’re taking that into consideration. If one tactic is drawing half the leads of another, but 50 percent more are qualified, that’s a tactic you’ll want to stick with. Take quality over quantity every time.

Vol. 6, Issue 10

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Digital

Scott Worthington, vice president of product management at Reynolds and Reynolds, stands indoors in front of large windows wearing a navy blazer and white shirt.
Digitalby StaffMarch 3, 2026

Reynolds, Corpay Partner to Enhance Dealership Payables

The new connection between the companies is designed to help digitize payments, targeting smoother transactions for automotive dealers.

Read More →
Headshot of Zach Shefska, CEO of CarEdge, alongside the CarEdge logo on a blue background.
Digitalby StaffFebruary 24, 2026

Free Public Scoring System Rewards Honest Dealer Prices

CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index is based on verified quotes, and retailers can be rewarded with badges and other marketable proofs of honest pricing.

Read More →
Graphic promoting StoneEagle at the 2026 NADA Show in Las Vegas, featuring a photo of CEO Cindy Allen.
Product & Technologyby StaffJanuary 20, 2026

StoneEagle to Unveil Next-Gen F&I Solutions at NADA

Empowering the F&I office through data is central to the company’s reimagined solutions it's scheduled to debut soon.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Digitalby Hannah MitchellJanuary 9, 2026

Automaker Websites Valuable Tools

The majority of shoppers visit them, and most undecided consumers consider the brands whose sites they peruse, but some automakers emphasize brand over product detail.

Read More →
Product & Technologyby Hannah MitchellNovember 25, 2025

AI-Guided Car-Shopping Insight

Consumers say they’re using the tech, but many still end up at dealerships to seal the deal.

Read More →
A smartphone displaying a Hertz Car Sales online listing sits beside the Cox Automotive logo, illustrating Cox’s new omnichannel car-buying platform.
Digitalby StaffNovember 11, 2025

Omnichannel Car-Buying Platform Launches

Cox Automotive says the technology enables online transactions on client sites and third-party marketplaces simultaneously.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Digitalby Hannah MitchellOctober 31, 2025

Audi Drivers Can Ditch That Pesky Manual

Updated mobile app features AI assistant for tech questions, EV tasks and more

Read More →
Digitalby Hannah MitchellOctober 24, 2025

GM Cars to Get Smarter Over Time

Automaker announces single vehicle computing system to connect lineup for faster updates

Read More →
Shawn Concannon, president of TSD Mobility Solutions, stands inside a modern office building, representing TSD’s continued growth in connected-fleet technology.
Digitalby StaffOctober 14, 2025

TSD Mobility Acquisition to Bolster Telematics

Latest addition expands connected-fleet technology, strengthening telematics capabilities and global reach

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Digitalby Hannah MitchellSeptember 5, 2025

Cyber Threats Continue Apace

Hackers, seeing auto retail vulnerabilities in 2024 CDK incident, are taking advantage, data show.

Read More →