auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

New Car Leads Are not Always New Car Buyers

Jason Ezell - ... of all the traffic (actual visitors) you get to your dealership Web site, 42 percent have not even decided whether to buy a new or pre-owned vehicle ...

Jason Ezell
Jason EzellPresident and Co-Founder
Read Jason's Posts
November 11, 2008
3 min to read


Back when I was selling cars, I was convinced I could outsell any objection from a buyer—color, options, new versus used, finance versus lease. My GM’s favorite quote was, “There’s a seat on this lot for every customer.” His point was clear, “I don’t care what they said they wanted; they’re driving off in what we sell them.” Well, he was correct about half of the time.

There is a perception that Internet shoppers know exactly what they want and selling them something different will probably be impossible. I hear many dealers say they’d sell more cars from the Internet if they only had the right vehicle in stock. What?! Several Internet salespeople say they sometimes won’t even respond to a lead if it’s for a vehicle they don’t have in stock. “We’re not going to get the deal anyway; we don’t have that vehicle. Why should I waste my time?”

Ad Loading...

Very similar to offline shoppers, in 2006, 58 percent of online shoppers who submitted a lead via the Internet actually bought a different vehicle than what they submitted a lead for. In fact, of all the traffic (actual visitors) you get to your dealership Web site, 42 percent have not even decided whether to buy a new or pre-owned vehicle.

Even better, 42 percent of buyers who submitted a new-car lead drove home in a pre-owned beauty. Of those new-car lead submitters, 20 percent bought a pre-owned vehicle within 30 days of submitting a lead, while over half (53 percent) bought a pre-owned vehicle within 90 days of submitting a new-car lead. So, as a new-vehicle lead gets older, the likelihood of that new-car shopper buying a previously-owned vehicle increases dramatically.

You see how all of this applies to lot ups and Internet ups? Granted, Internet ups might be more informed; they probably have trade values, invoice, etc. Since 2004, the number of people who drive onto dealers’ lots looking for pre-owned cars has dropped from 62 percent to 56 percent. Do you think it’s simply chance that the number of people going on the Internet to find that same vehicle has increased by almost exactly the same amount?

So even with Internet ups, we should default back to what we do best: 1) keep in mind what vehicle they say they want, 2) get to know the customer and his/her needs and 3) show vehicles that you know fulfill those needs, new and pre-owned. And the next time a salesperson comes to you and says, “We don’t have the vehicle they are looking for,” keep your cool and say, “There’s a seat on this lot for every customer!” Then, hand them this article and tell them to call me.

*Statistics Sourced from JD Power 2006 Automotive Internet Shopper Study.

Vol 5, Issue 10

Topics:BDCDigital
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Digital

Portrait of Cox Automotive President Steve Rowley alongside company logo, representing acquisition of Fullpath to enhance AI-driven data and marketing solutions for auto dealers.
Digitalby StaffApril 24, 2026

Cox Automotive to Acquire Fullpath

The company says the deal brings artificial intelligence-native data and marketing infrastructure to its dealer network for a unified platform.

Read More →
hands making protective frame over red car, Risk Reality Check, Be Proactive, Auto Dealer Today logo
Dealer OpsApril 1, 2026

Managing Risk Effectively Through Changing Times

The variables influencing risk pricing have changed significantly over the past five years. Being proactive and responsive to emerging trends is not optional but essential.

Read More →
Dealer Debrief 03/31/2026 with Lauren Lawrence. headshot of Lauren Lawrence. Auto Dealer Today logo.
Digitalby Lauren LawrenceMarch 31, 2026

Dealer Debrief: EV Sales, Brand Loyalty & More

In this week's Dealer Debrief, host Lauren Lawrence covers EV sales, tire brand loyalty, and new industry executive leaders.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Scott Worthington, vice president of product management at Reynolds and Reynolds, stands indoors in front of large windows wearing a navy blazer and white shirt.
Digitalby StaffMarch 3, 2026

Reynolds, Corpay Partner to Enhance Dealership Payables

The new connection between the companies is designed to help digitize payments, targeting smoother transactions for automotive dealers.

Read More →
mechanic filling out clipboard while inspecting under hood of vehicle
DigitalMarch 1, 2026

Owner Retention Stakes Have Never Been Higher

Service advisers represent dealerships’ foundation in fostering ongoing customer loyalty, and they must maintain certain standards to keep that foundation strong.

Read More →
Headshot of Zach Shefska, CEO of CarEdge, alongside the CarEdge logo on a blue background.
Digitalby StaffFebruary 24, 2026

Free Public Scoring System Rewards Honest Dealer Prices

CarEdge Dealer Transparency Index is based on verified quotes, and retailers can be rewarded with badges and other marketable proofs of honest pricing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Digitalby Hannah MitchellJanuary 9, 2026

Automaker Websites Valuable Tools

The majority of shoppers visit them, and most undecided consumers consider the brands whose sites they peruse, but some automakers emphasize brand over product detail.

Read More →
Digitalby Hannah MitchellNovember 25, 2025

AI-Guided Car-Shopping Insight

Consumers say they’re using the tech, but many still end up at dealerships to seal the deal.

Read More →
A smartphone displaying a Hertz Car Sales online listing sits beside the Cox Automotive logo, illustrating Cox’s new omnichannel car-buying platform.
Digitalby StaffNovember 11, 2025

Omnichannel Car-Buying Platform Launches

Cox Automotive says the technology enables online transactions on client sites and third-party marketplaces simultaneously.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Digitalby Hannah MitchellOctober 31, 2025

Audi Drivers Can Ditch That Pesky Manual

Updated mobile app features AI assistant for tech questions, EV tasks and more

Read More →