auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Sheehy.com Increases Leads Over 300 Percent in 60 Days

Sean Wolfington - Sheehy sold an additional 414 cars in one month online while decreasing their advertising costs...

3 min to read


Sheehy sold an additional 414 cars in one month online while decreasing their advertising costs. “We shifted some of our marketing budget to focus on targeting the Internet. Customers are changing where and how they shop so we are changing where we market. We’ve found the Web is a lot less expensive than traditional mass media, and it’s easy to measure the returns,” said Roy Reutter from Sheehy. “Initially we relied heavily on third party providers for our leads and after a short time, we realized that the leads with the highest closing ratio and lowest cost came from our own Web site. We’ve since set up our own regional buying service, and we’re generating more traffic and leads for our people to turn into appointments and sales. The Web has become our primary source of phone traffic,” Reutter said. The Idea Once the Sheehy team realized they needed more than a Web site and a few third party lead providers, they worked to build a complete strategy to market and update their Web site, staff their team, implement a process, establish pricing and more. That was two years ago and since that time they have increased their numbers by over 600 percent and dropped their cost per sale to about $130 per car. The Results After switching to the new provider, Sheehy increased leads from 400 to 1,350 in the first two months and have continued to improve results. Today they are generating more than 2,400 leads a month from their Web site alone. They’re selling more than 400 cars a month online. The Web site Roy Reutter has found there are five keys to a great automotive Web site. They are:

  • Simple and easy to use

  • Content that the customer wants

  • High-impact, engaging multi-media fast to load even on a low-speed connection

  • Automatic updating for inventory, specials and pricing

  • Designed to create more Internet, phone and showroom traffic

Ad Loading...

The Marketing According to Reutter, the Sheey Auto Stores have been able to generate more traffic at a lower cost per sale by using search engine optimization in conjunction with multi-media buzz mail campaigns blended with traditional marketing strategies. As a result, customers are landing at www.Sheehy.com rather than at the competitors’ sites. “If you can’t generate traffic there’s no point in having a Web site,” Reutter said. The Bottom Line

  • Sheehy sold 414 cars online by shifting some of their advertising.

  • After launching the new Web site Sheehy went from 400 leads to 1,350 leads in only 60 days and today they generate over 2,400 leads per month.

  • The closing ratio or the leads from www.Sheehy.com is three to four times higher and the cost/sale averages $130.

  • www.Sheehy.com is designed to drive phone and showroom traffic. The Web site is now the top source of phone leads.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Dealer Ops

Cover image for a BOK Financial report titled “Timing the market: How avoiding volatility entirely can hurt long-term reinsurance program performance.” The image shows several road construction barricades with flashing amber warning lights lined up in a nighttime work zone. Beneath the image, red text explains that avoiding volatility can mean falling behind inflation and missing market rebounds that drive long-term surplus growth. The BOK Financial logo appears at the bottom right.
SponsoredMay 8, 2026

Timing the Market Can Hurt Long-Term Program Performance

For dealer-owned reinsurance entities, avoiding volatility entirely can mean falling behind inflation and missing market rebounds that drive long term surplus growth. Missing just a handful of strong market days can materially impact cumulative returns—an important reminder for long horizon trust and investment strategies.

Read More →
two cars on a billboard, No Hidden Fees
ComplianceMay 1, 2026

Dealer Ads and the FTC

The agency has made it clear in recent enforcement actions and warnings, in auto retail and other industries, that advertised prices must include all nonoptional costs to the consumer.

Read More →
Closeup of white car's headlight, front end
Dealer Opsby Hannah MitchellApril 17, 2026

Used Autos Supply Dwindles

The March shopping surge, despite high prices, cut into inventory by the most since the thick of the pandemic, Cox Automotive analysts calculated.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
hands making protective frame over red car, Risk Reality Check, Be Proactive, Auto Dealer Today logo
Dealer OpsApril 1, 2026

Managing Risk Effectively Through Changing Times

The variables influencing risk pricing have changed significantly over the past five years. Being proactive and responsive to emerging trends is not optional but essential.

Read More →
Car key, stacks of coins, and a paper car cutout with AutoPayPlus logo, representing auto financing, loan terms, and vehicle affordability trends.
Dealer Opsby StaffMarch 31, 2026

Survey Reveals What Won't Fix What's Breaking Car Sales

AutoPayPlus says extra-long auto loans are trapping consumers and threatening the dealer trade-in cycle, and that the industry is leveraging the wrong tools to combat high MSRPs.

Read More →
Headshots of two male executives
Dealer Opsby StaffMarch 24, 2026

IA American Appoints Two Execs

Senior vice presidents of the company's agent and dealer channels chosen to support general agents and help auto dealers with sales and performance.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Dealer Opsby StaffSeptember 8, 2025

Cox Automotive Acquires Inspection Firm

Full ownership of Alliance Inspection Management, or AiM, meant to unlock growth for Manheim inspection capabilities

Read More →
Dealer Opsby StaffAugust 26, 2025

Assurant Expands Partnership With Holman

Extended collaboration delivers training, products and performance development to 30 newly acquired Holman dealerships

Read More →
Dealer Opsby Hannah MitchellAugust 26, 2025

Franchises, Throughput Down in First Half

A handful of states see franchise growth through June, while EV sales per store boost overall business in U.S.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Dealer OpsAugust 25, 2025

How to Build a High-Performance Sales and F&I Team

Performance and profits start with people chosen and led the right way.

Read More →