Tom Lyons Joins Polly as President and Chief Operating Officer of Insurance
In the role, Lyons will be responsible for Polly's insurance platform, including agency distribution, book performance, written premium, revenue, earning recognition, sales and service.

In the role, Lyons will be responsible for Polly's insurance platform, including agency distribution, book performance, written premium, revenue, earning recognition, sales and service.
BURLINGTON, Vt. – Polly (formerly known as DealerPolicy), a leading insurance marketplace for automotive retail, has named Tom Lyons as the company's President and Chief Operating Officer of Insurance. Effective today, Lyons reports directly to Travis Fitzgerald, Co-Founder and CEO at Polly.
In the role, Lyons will be responsible for Polly's insurance platform, including agency distribution, book performance, written premium, revenue, earning recognition, sales and service. He will also oversee product, marketing, operations, underwriting, and analytics.
An accomplished insurance leader, Lyons joins Polly after serving as Plymouth Rock's Chief Operating Officer, overseeing their Direct Response business as well as their Captive (Prudential Financial Advisor) Agency business. During his 15-year tenure at Plymouth Rock, Lyons built out and oversaw the company's direct-to-consumer marketing and sales efforts, marketing analytical activities and inbound and outbound Sales Center operations. In addition, Lyons oversaw Plymouth Rock's strategic partnerships with InsurTech agencies throughout the country, as well as all affinity partnerships inclusive of Teacher's Insurance Plan of NJ, and led their Rider Insurance Motorcycle product line.
"Tom's extensive experience building high-performance teams and leading enterprise personal insurance operations will further accelerate scale for Polly," said Fitzgerald. "His knowledge of the ever-changing insurance distribution landscape and the shifting needs of car buyers will be invaluable as our company enters an exciting new chapter."
"I'm thrilled to be joining the entrepreneurial and passionate team at Polly," said Lyons. "Consumers now require the ease of buying insurance on their terms, through their own preferred channel, while still feeling well served and informed. Polly is meeting this need, and I look forward to working with the Polly team to pave a quicker path to quote and purchase for improved overall customer experiences for car buyers."
More Awards

iA American Marks Another Year of Dealers’ Choice Awards
The company points out its multiple recognitions over consecutive years in the annual Bobit Business Media honors chosen by auto dealership staffs.
Read More →
Winners of 2026 Dealers’ Choice Awards Announced
Now in its 22nd year, the DCAs were designed to recognize the best vendors, suppliers, and finance partners in the industry, by asking dealership personnel to complete a 27-category online survey.
Read More →
AAA Honors Service and Repair Facilities
Three automotive dealerships made AAA's Service Providers of Excellence and Best in Repair list this year.
Read More →
Voting Period for 2026 Dealers' Choice Awards Ends June 30
Voting for the 22nd annual Dealers’ Choice Awards will remain open until the end of day.
Read More →
IIHS Adds to Safety Rankings
A midsize Hyundai and a small Toyota have joined the nonprofit's 2026 Top Safety Pick+ award rankings, thanks to improved crash test results and crash-prevention measures.
Read More →
Time Dealer of the Year Named
David Wright of Iowa rises to the top of nearly 50 nominees across the country on his record of business growth and contributions to his dealership’s community.
Read More →

Automakers Take Home Safety Awards
Tweaks to models put them over the top while others miss out due to substandard crash test results
Read More →
Child Seats Easier to Install in Some Cars
Annual testing scored 2025 models on ease across five categories.
Read More →
5 Industry Legends Join F&I Hall of Fame
The second annual induction recognized luminaries who helped advance F&I training, production, compliance, agency-building and product development.
Read More →