auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Develop a Multi-State Survival Mode

Hal Scott - A few wrong decisions today and even those dealers fortunate enough to have old family money could easily be gone. This is not a revelation for many of you, as fear for financial survival has savagely ripped through every...

April 9, 2009
4 min to read


A few wrong decisions today and even those dealers fortunate enough to have old family money could easily be gone. This is not a revelation for many of you, as fear for financial survival has savagely ripped through every U.S. market and every industry-related business in the past 90 days.

Many of today’s dealers have never had to face what stands before them today. The financial crisis has the potential to end dealers’ livelihoods and brings with it little belief that recovery will arrive within the foreseeable future.

Ad Loading...

Have any or all of the following questions gone through your mind recently? (More like every day, right?)

• Will my manufacturer survive?

• Can I survive until the market rebounds?

• If my manufacturer survives, will I still have a store if the manufacture reduces its number of franchised dealerships by 25 percent to 50 percent?

A large percentage of “Big 3” stores have downsized their overall operations by at least 20 percent over the past two years, and many by much more than that. This storm has been brewing for a long time. Most are on their third wave of substantial personnel restructures or cuts. The problem remains that many are still far from profitable, and without question, the worst is yet to come.

Ad Loading...

Yet, even as dark as times appear today, dealers are a very resilient group of entrepreneurs who normally find ways to continue their existence because they are driven by the optimistic, risk-taking, never-say-die spirit of American capitalism.

In today’s dealership, we have found the Achilles-heel to be one of the following:

1.  Dealerships are failing to respond quickly enough or measurably enough to stem their losses, resulting in irreversible financial demise.

2.  An entrepreneurial spirit (in this case, pride) refuses to, or reluctantly accepts, collaborative guidance that could lead to a successful survival solution. Many times an asset can become a liability.

I would contend that like the manufacturers, many dealerships are just two or three bad decisions away from complete financial collapse. Conversely, the same dealerships may be just two or three good decisions away from a survival model that will allow them to not only stay in business, but to prosper in a future market with a significant percentage of their competitors gone.

 What must every dealership do or understand today to improve their chances of being around tomorrow?

Ad Loading...

• Improve today’s revenues by maximizing your current opportunities.

• Develop a survival model that ensures you will be able to succeed tomorrow, if not today.

• A survival model is not one-size-fits-all. Your survival model can utilize best practices and successful pieces of survival models from other dealerships, but it will still need to be tailored specifically to your store’s needs.

• A multi-stage survival model should be developed before things get critical in your store. Panic can lead to less-than-perfect decision making.

What does a dealership survival model need to include or at least take into consideration? Again, there is no one-size-fits-all, but listed below are many of the things you need to address today. A percentage of dealers will not be able to stomach what they need to do to survive. My experience is that developing a survival model does not come without varying levels of grief, anger and humility, but a survival model is essential.

Ad Loading...

• What will the consequences of inaction be?

• Am I in it for the long haul, or should I quit/sell?

• Who should be included in planning the survival business model?

• Should I make a business model presentation to stakeholders?

• What is the value of experienced guidance?

Ad Loading...

• How do I balance staff and compensation reductions?

• Are there associated internal and external image concerns?

• Who are my most valuable employees?

• Which employees will remain loyal to me, and how can I know?

• Which survival compensation model will work best in my store?

Ad Loading...

• How will I implement a successful survival model?

• If employees share the pain, should they share the gain?

• What can I do to improve staff perceptions to increase success and performance?

• Do we return to old business models in the future, or can a survival model be a long-term success model with superior team benefits?

These are just a few of the decisions and thoughts you need to consider today. Don’t wait too long to developed your survival model. Time is not your friend if you are not properly prepared.

Ad Loading...

Vol 6, Issue 2

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fixed Ops

Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 10/16/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•October 16, 2026

The Fixed Ops Blind Spot | Dealer Debrief

Customer-pay repair orders only make up about 5% of a service department’s repair orders. Is your dealership missing out on this profitable service?

Read More →
pair of hands holding tools working on a vehicle under the hood
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•October 9, 2026

The Fixed Ops Blind Spot

Customer-pay repair orders are profitability drivers for service departments, but many dealerships don't know how much of their business goes to them.

Read More →
White backlit BRZ sitting in front of mechanic.
Fixed Ops•by Staff•October 8, 2026

ASE Invites Service Centers to Benchmark Performance

ASE Connects is gathering the data for its quarterly service snapshot report, which provides a comparison of service drives across the country.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Mechanic holding digital device over an open vehicle engine
Fixed Ops•by Hannah Mitchell•October 2, 2026

More Cars Recalled in First Half

The six months that kicked off the year saw an extended surge of the number of vehicles recalled, electrical issues leading the way again.

Read More →
Mechanic's hand picking through a toolbox
Fixed Ops•by Staff•August 25, 2026

California Dealer Group Foundation Partners With ASE

CNCDA Foundation and ASE Connects collaboration is intended to build California's automotive technician workforce.

Read More →
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 08/19/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•August 20, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Fixed-Ops Opportunities

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses maximizing your dealership's profitability with a focus on fixed operations.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 07/23/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•July 24, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Technician Apprenticeships

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses a new grant for service tech apprenticeships and more industry workforce news.

Read More →
Photo of metal tools on a surface
Fixed Ops•by Staff•July 2, 2026

ASE Acquires WrenchWay

The auto technician certification nonprofit said the deal expands its role in workforce-development and support for current and future service professionals.

Read More →
Photo of tire on white car
Fixed Ops•by Staff•June 29, 2026

TraXtion Introduces TireSpec Website Solution

The company says the offering enables consumers to snap a photo of their tire with a smartphone and receive an instant replacement quote, capturing 90% of tire shoppers who start their shopping online.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of white SUV in garage with graphic explaining car photo process
Fixed Ops•by Staff•June 15, 2026

UVeye Launches Same-Day Vehicle Listings for Car Dealers

New 'Scan to Sold' offering turns the service lane into a website-ready merchandising photo booth designed to help dealerships reduce turnaround time from days to minutes.

Read More →