auto dealer in black and red logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Service Retention: The Value of Your Service Advisor

Harlene Doane - A recent manufacturer study indicated a sharp rise in the chance of selling a customer another vehicle based on the number of times they visit your service department. A single service visit increased that chance by 29 percent...

Harlene Doane
Harlene DoaneEditor / Director Of Operations
Read Harlene's Posts
June 9, 2008
4 min to read


A recent manufacturer study indicated a sharp rise in the chance of selling a customer another vehicle based on the number of times they visit your service department. A single service visit increased that chance by 29 percent. Five visits ratcheted the odds up to 40 percent. Increase service profits and vehicle sales—the best of both worlds!

Is it really that simple? No, because driving the customer back to the service department can be a fairly significant challenge if your staff is not trained properly. Service retention takes effort and more importantly, it takes properly trained individuals to execute it. How much time do you spend developing your service advisors.?

Most manufacturers do a good job of requiring the sales team to pass proficiency tests on product lines. Many dealerships even have daily sales training programs in place, but how many have the same in place for their service advisors? 

Look at the facts:
The service advisor comes in contact with more customers daily than any sales person, sometimes more than the entire sales staff. On average, the service advisor generates more gross profit per person than the sales staff.



Benchmark Departmental Gross Profit 
per Average Month **


Salesperson

Service Advisor

Highline

$52,393 

$38,486 

Import 

$36,203 

$23,002 

Domestic 

$34,852 

$22,777 


How much of your budget is spent on training your service advisors?

You don’t need to reinvent the wheel to improve your service operation; you just need to implement some “best practices.” It starts with the service appointment. Eliminate the service advisor from the role of booking appointments. The service advisor will often schedule appointments based on his personal agenda instead of shop capacity. If you have a BDC in place, allow the BDC to schedule appointments based on shop capacity.  If you do not have a BDC in place, find someone else who can be trained to handle the scheduling instead of the service advisor.

When the customer arrives, the service advisor should have sufficient time to conduct a walk-around of the vehicle, address primary concerns, suggest any maintenance or recall work, and come to an agreement of work to be performed. Additionally, there should be an agreement as to how to contact the customer upon completion or if a question arises during the work.

When the repairs are complete, an active delivery should take place. More and more, an active delivery is one in which the service advisor fulfills the role of the service cashier. The service advisor is the person who’s best equipped to handle any explanation of services or to answer any questions the customer may have regarding the repairs. This leads to a much stronger and more positive customer experience.

Before the customer leaves, schedule his or her next maintenance appointment. It’s no different than your hairdresser. This person knows your hair grows x amount over x time and based on your hairstyle you will need a trim in five weeks. Because of this, your hairdresser asks to set the appointment in five weeks. You might choose four or even six weeks but usually you will schedule at that time and even if you have to reschedule you rarely cancel.

Implement the same practice in your service department. The service advisor has the driving history of the customer and knows the scheduled maintenance, making it easy to calculate when the next service would likely be due.  The service advisor can simply say, “Mr. Jones, based on your driving patterns, your vehicle would be due for scheduled maintenance about July 15th. Would you prefer a morning appointment like today?”

Why wait on vehicle sales to dip before you focus your attention on your fixed operations? If you invest in training these valuable individuals in the service department today, you can weather any sales storm on the horizon.


**All benchmarks are compliments of NCM Associates and have been provided by Kevin Cunningham, director of business development.  Question, concerns or comments regarding benchmarks or Twenty Group programs can be e-mailed to Twenty@AutoDealerMonthly.com

Vol 5, Issue 4


Benchmark Departmental Gross Profit 
per Average Month **


Salesperson

Service Advisor

Highline

$52,393 

$38,486 

Import 

$36,203 

$23,002 

Domestic 

$34,852 

$22,777 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fixed Ops

Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 10/16/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•October 16, 2026

The Fixed Ops Blind Spot | Dealer Debrief

Customer-pay repair orders only make up about 5% of a service department’s repair orders. Is your dealership missing out on this profitable service?

Read More →
pair of hands holding tools working on a vehicle under the hood
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•October 9, 2026

The Fixed Ops Blind Spot

Customer-pay repair orders are profitability drivers for service departments, but many dealerships don't know how much of their business goes to them.

Read More →
White backlit BRZ sitting in front of mechanic.
Fixed Ops•by Staff•October 8, 2026

ASE Invites Service Centers to Benchmark Performance

ASE Connects is gathering the data for its quarterly service snapshot report, which provides a comparison of service drives across the country.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Mechanic holding digital device over an open vehicle engine
Fixed Ops•by Hannah Mitchell•October 2, 2026

More Cars Recalled in First Half

The six months that kicked off the year saw an extended surge of the number of vehicles recalled, electrical issues leading the way again.

Read More →
Mechanic's hand picking through a toolbox
Fixed Ops•by Staff•August 25, 2026

California Dealer Group Foundation Partners With ASE

CNCDA Foundation and ASE Connects collaboration is intended to build California's automotive technician workforce.

Read More →
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 08/19/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•August 20, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Fixed-Ops Opportunities

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses maximizing your dealership's profitability with a focus on fixed operations.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Auto Dealer Today, Dealer Debrief, 07/23/2026, with Lauren Lawrence
Fixed Ops•by Lauren Lawrence•July 24, 2026

Dealer Debrief: Technician Apprenticeships

In this week's debrief, host Lauren Lawrence discusses a new grant for service tech apprenticeships and more industry workforce news.

Read More →
Photo of metal tools on a surface
Fixed Ops•by Staff•July 2, 2026

ASE Acquires WrenchWay

The auto technician certification nonprofit said the deal expands its role in workforce-development and support for current and future service professionals.

Read More →
Photo of tire on white car
Fixed Ops•by Staff•June 29, 2026

TraXtion Introduces TireSpec Website Solution

The company says the offering enables consumers to snap a photo of their tire with a smartphone and receive an instant replacement quote, capturing 90% of tire shoppers who start their shopping online.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of white SUV in garage with graphic explaining car photo process
Fixed Ops•by Staff•June 15, 2026

UVeye Launches Same-Day Vehicle Listings for Car Dealers

New 'Scan to Sold' offering turns the service lane into a website-ready merchandising photo booth designed to help dealerships reduce turnaround time from days to minutes.

Read More →