Captive Auto Lenders Behind on Digital
Consumers demanding efficient, seamless online experiences as they shop for loans, survey finds

The study found that many lenders, especially noncaptives, have much room for improvement to meet today’s consumer expectations.
Pexels/Lisa
Mercedes’ auto lending arm is setting the pace on consumer digital experiences in a market that increasingly values high-quality online presences.
A third annual J.D. Power study on digital auto finance channels shows how much consistent experiences on auto lender websites and applications and smooth transitions between those and offline communications increase customer engagement, satisfaction and loyalty.
“Channel consistency is still the name of the game in any digital financial services user experience,” said Senior Director of Digital Solutions Jon Sundberg.
A good digital experience yields positive customer results, according to the study. The vast majority of consumers who used a lender with a high digital satisfaction score said they’d definitely use its website or mobile app again.
Consumers’ increasing use of artificial intelligence tools to shop for auto loans is raising the pressure to polish digital channels. But the study found that despite progress, many lenders have much room for improvement to meet today’s consumer expectations, especially noncaptives.
Mercedes-Benz Financial Services nevertheless outscored all captive and noncaptive lenders on digital experience in the study with a score of 746. In fact, German luxury automakers swept the captive segment of the industry, Audi in second place at 740, and BMW third at 727.
Among noncaptives, Bank of America led with a score of 741, followed by Chase Auto at 730, and Wells Fargo at 715.
Noncaptive lenders have improved their mobile apps for a two-point score increase to 704, 20 points above captives’ 684.
“A great digital experience is becoming a crucial component of customer retention,” said J.D. Power Senior Director of Automotive Finance Intelligence Patrick Roosenberg. “As more vehicle shoppers start using artificial intelligence and other digital tools to shop for their next auto loan, it will be critical for lenders to have a meaningful digital connection with existing loan customers so they stay top-of-mind throughout that process.”
He said banks are overall outscoring captive lenders digitally because they developed sophisticated digital channels for other parts of their business. With that and some captives’ digital groundwork, “the playbook of best practices is starting to become much clearer and there are huge opportunities for improvement in this space.”
J.D. Power surveyed nearly 6,500 auto finance consumers who used a lender’s website or mobile app.
More Industry

Automaker Advances Safety for All
A new report by Volvo Cars Safety Centre analyzed the impact of 50 years' worth of research in automotive safety development
Read More →
Kentucky Store Leaves Family
An auto group stretched across three states picked up the Lexington-area Ford fixture as its second store for the brand in the state.
Read More →
U.S. Auto Brands Falling Behind
Asian auto brands are outpacing U.S. brands in stateside new-vehicle sales. Learn more in this week's Dealer Debrief with Lauren!
Read More →
U.S. EV Market Update | Dealer Debrief
The U.S. electric vehicle market is slowly recovering from the loss of the federal EV tax credit last fall. Learn more in this week's Dealer Debrief!
Read More →
Auto Finance Numbers Set Records
Third-quarter data show how consumers are adapting to ongoing affordability challenges facing the new- and-used-vehicle markets.
Read More →
Auto Dealerships Can’t Afford to Ignore the 50+ Consumer
Younger generations may be all the buzz today when it comes to product marketing targets, but their older cohorts command a sizable share of purchasing power.
Read More →
Savings Seekers Boost U.S. Automakers’ Rivals
As consumers here look for ways to curb inflation’s affect on their budgets, brands offering plenty of alternative powertrains are closing in on home-grown OEMs.
Read More →
The Slow Electric Ascent
Second-quarter data show that the electric-vehicle market in the U.S. is inching up, the majority of states seeing a month-over-month increase.
Read More →
Safer Rides & Cyberattacks
Vehicle crash testing is getting a virtual boost, but auto dealerships are facing increased cyberattacks. Learn more in this week's Dealer Debrief!
Read More →
Affordability Angst | Dealer Debrief
August saw little relief for car buyers, whether they were shopping new or used. Take a look at the month's breakdown in this week's Dealer Debrief!
Read More →